This page serves only to provide a historical perspective of the activity to  improve street signs from April 1999 to July 2000.  To review the current plan, refer to Community - Street Signs

pencil-blue-450.gif (1539 bytes)

10 July, 2000
Sydney Morning Herald prints feature article on Navigator's Paradise in Sydney Forum. Streets signs do not appear on agenda for Hornsby Shire Council's July 12 Ordinary Meeting; next one is August 9. Your letters are still valuable as detailed at end of April entry below, but should now voice support for naming both streets at intersections and/or the Lifesaver sign. Those letters should reach Street Signs by August 8 at the latest, but the earlier the better.
.
7 March, 2000
B. Player makes presentation to Standards Australia. Members of Committee take home documentation on Wedge Notation and are to to give committee project director their opinions by Easter. Committee finalises kerb numbering specifications for first amendment to AS1742.5--1997, due out later in 2000.
.
5 April, 2000
If you want to support Wedge notation, you must act now.

Thank you for reading Wedge Notation.
This new scheme is supported in writing by
bulletAndrew Tink MP, NSW Shadow Minister for Policing
bulletCllr Steven Pringle, (now Deputy) Mayor, Hornsby Shire
bulletSupt Jack Williams, Commander, Eastwood Local Area Command, NSW Police
bulletSupt Stephen Gray, Superintendent Zone N2, Region North, NSW Fire Brigades
bulletSupt Don Hart, North Sydney and Central Coast Area Manager, Ambulance Service of NSW
bulletMore than 47 individuals and community groups from seven Sydney council areas

To evaluate the success of the Navigator’s Paradise trial, in July 1999 Hornsby Shire Council officers circulated a survey questionnaire to residents of the trial area and to a second group described below. Survey results were presented to Council on 9 February 2000. Wedge notation was selected by 52% of 285 responding residents, 88% of whom were familiar with the signs, as the most effective of three methods for showing property numbers on signs.

Council had delayed for more than two years the use of its new sign while awaiting the results of this trial. If the trial showed Wedge notation to be successful, and they extended its use throughout the Shire, it could open the way for other councils to adopt the scheme.

In their report of February 9, however, council officers recommended against the use of Wedge notation on Hornsby Shire’s new signs. This recommendation was based almost entirely on the responses of the second group surveyed, which was comprised of the 39 other metropolitan councils and the emergency service providers for the Hornsby-Ku-ring-gai area. Of the 47 respondents in this group, only 38% were familiar with the signs. 62% knew nothing of Wedge notation, which, it has always been acknowledged, would need an initial education campaign. It is not surprising that only 17% of this group selected Wedge notation as the most effective option, while 55% selected the Australian Standard, which is flawed (see Figure 2 in Wedge Notation).

I protested that the data did not support the recommendations because more weight was being given to the responses of 47 responding ill-informed "stakeholders," few of whom would have even visited the trial area, than to the responses of 285 well-informed residents, whose choice was clearly the Wedge scheme. I also protested that the report contained no mention of any of the written support listed above.

Council resolved to defer a decision for three months (until May 10) while it explored the interest of neighbouring councils and Standards Australia in Wedge notation.

On March 7 I presented the scheme to a meeting of the Roads Signs and Traffic Signals committee at Standards Australia, whose members will give their individual opinions on its merit in due course. If favourably viewed by them, it could eventually be incorporated into the Standard, at least as an option, but only after more extensive testing.

If you feel Wedge notation has merit—if you would like to one day see it used throughout Sydney—I urge you to send the letter given below. Hornsby Shire’s Councillors displayed vision and courage in 1997 when they agreed to trial this new and unproven scheme on 16 signs. This next step requires much greater courage. Whether or not they take that step depends entirely on their conviction that there is enough support for it. Your vote definitely matters.

I will see that your vote reaches not only Hornsby Shire Council but also your own council, Standards Australia, and the Local Government Association. But I must have your letters by May 5.

I also urge you to give this letter and your copy of Wedge Notation to an associate.

Thank you.

Yours for better signage

Beatrice Player

NB: If you would like to study in detail this scheme applied in a variety of situations, please phone 9876 5993 for a copy of The Wedge At Work, prepared for Standards Australia and for councils who might consider the use of Wedge notation.

Sample Letter:

To the Councillors of Hornsby Shire:
I would like you to adopt Wedge notation for Hornsby Shire’s new street name signs.
I live in ______________________________ Council.
(Add anything else you wish.)
YOUR NAME AND ADDRESS
.
Mail before May 5 to: 

STREET SIGNS
PO Box 134
EPPING NSW 1710

.

9 February 2000
B. Player receives invitation from Standards Australia to speak at March 7 meeting of Road Signs and Traffic Signals Committee. Topics will be 1) adding a new section on kerb numbering to Australian Standard 1742.5, Street Name and Community Facility Name Signs, and 2) the Navigator’s Paradise trial and Wedge Notation.
.
9 February 2000.
Hornsby Shire Council engineers present to Council the results of the July survey of residents and stakeholders. Of three ways of displaying property numbers on signs, 52% of 285 responding residents (88% of whom were familiar with the trailled sign) picked Wedge Notation as most effective. Residents very strongly supported naming both streets at virtually all intersections and displaying both property numbers and suburb name on signs.

Also surveyed were two groups of stakeholders: emergency service personnel in the Hornsby-Ku-ring-gai area and officers from the 39 other Sydney councils. Of the three ways of displaying property numbers, 55% of 47 responding combined stakeholders (38% of whom were familiar with the trailled sign) picked the Australian Standard as most effective. Combined stakeholders supported all other aspects of the trial although their feelings were not as strong as the residents’.

Hornsby Shire Council resolve to defer a decision for three months while they explore any interest of other councils and Standards Australia in the Wedge.
.

27 July 1999.
Hornsby Shire Council engineers have surveyed residents of the Navigator’s Paradise pilot project area (the Dence Park area of Epping, bounded by Epping Road, Blaxland Road and Terrys Creek.) and are compiling a report on the effectiveness of the trial signs to present to Council. Council will base its decisions on whether to implement the trialled features throughout the shire on this report, and on written submissions from the general public and the emergency services.
.
26 July 1999.
NSW Member for Epping and Shadow Minister for Policing Andrew Tink joins police, fire and ambulance services with written support for all five measures trialled in Navigator’s Paradise. Hornsby Shire Council Mayor Steven Pringle continues as a prime supporter. Emergency services endorse leaner sign format.
.
24 May 1999.
B. Player presents summary of nine months of soft feedback to Hornsby Shire Council, reporting support in the community for all aspects of the trial, keen interest in property numbers on all signs, and acceptance, often enthusiastic, of the Wedge scheme once it is explained. Several aspects of the sign format had drawn criticism and a design engineer had submitted a drawing for a leaner format showing property numbers as large as street name.
.
22 April 1999.
EW3 Area Coordinator B. Player sends second letter to 40 councils containing feedback from trial. Requests funds in 1999-2000 budgets for signage upgrade pending outcome of trial, and asks for more uniformity in sign formats over the Sydney area..

Follow up articles or mentioned above -

bulletThe new sign language - Sydney Forum (Features & Arts) smh.com.au
bulletStreet Signs - Pennant Hills Civic Trust January 1999 Newsletter
bulletNeighbourhood Watch Welcome Newsletter
bulletStreet Signs flyer
bulletStreet Signs - FAQ & Feedback
bulletA historical perspective - the plan in July 1999
bullet Street Signs Timeline 1999 to 2000
pencil-blue-450.gif (1539 bytes)
Hit Counter
Page created - 27 July, 2001.  Page last updated - 14 August, 2006 15:08:49 +1000

Questions or comments?
Send e-mail to webmaster@tovegin.com.au
Copyright © 1998, 1999, 2000, 2001, 2002 Tovegin Pty Ltd (ACN 003 568 036)

Our Community

web site
designed &
maintained by

Tovegin Pty Ltd.
Tovegin P/L

a
Tovegin are a Registered Web Presence Developer for Microsoft® FrontPage®